Since this is back in the state forest, you need to travel along a gravel road for a few miles. Take Tannery Road for 1.2 miles and turn left onto Phelps Road. After .7 miles, Phelps road turns into a loop, so going straight or right will bring you back here. Turn right at this intersection and continue about 1.4 miles. Look for the trail that crosses the road called Pinchot Trail. There is no official parking area, but there are several small pull offs. The best one is on your left, maybe 1/8 mile before you cross the trail. Once you park, take Pinchot Trail to the right. However, this trail does not go to the waterfall. You will basically just find your way now through the forest. The goal is to follow Butler Run downstream, and there is an unnamed trail and paint markings on the trees. You will eventually hear the sound of Choke Creek, and then once you do, continue upstream following your ears!